Stylish and futuristic design; excellent sound quality; compatible with MP3, unprotected AAC, unprotected WMA and ATRAC3; includes useful, intelligent playlist and artist link features; replaceable battery; decent value
Uses a hard drive that's not as durable as flash; no extra features such as FM, recording and photo viewing; screen impossible to see in daylight and easy to scratch; imperfect SonicStage management software
The NW-A1200 is a one-dimensional player with subpar software integration, but it looks good, sounds great and includes innovative music search and playlist features
7.3 Very good
Reviewed by James Kim
Sony's 8GB NW-A1200 series is more or less identical to the 6GB NW-A1000. With an attractive design, good sound quality and some innovative firmware features, the A1200 should please those looking for music playback only. Just be aware that you'll be entering the Sony universe, which includes the notoriously counterintuitive SonicStage software.
Design
The A1200 measures 57 by 89 by 19mm, weighs 110g, and has a strikingly sexy design with a glossy plastic front and a scratch-proof metallic backside. It's a visual gem, coming in a rainbow of colours.
Inspired by the flash-based E505 series, the A1200's 35mm display hides below the surface of the reflective plastic exterior -- it shines through when powered on and creates a cool effect. The monochrome screen is bright and generally easy to read, though text is pixellated, and it's nearly impossible to read the display in daylight, where it makes a better mirror. Dazzling start-up graphics and rhythmically pulsating lights add to the A1200's appeal. The plastic scratches easily though, and is a veritable smudge magnet. Find a case for it, since Sony doesn't bundle one (Sony does bundle an AC adaptor, a proprietary USB cable, headphones and the SonicStage CP software).
Features
Keep in mind that this is a hard drive device, so you'll get more capacity for your buck (£159 vs. the £169 4GB iPod nano) in exchange for a larger form factor and potential hard drive-related problems (though Sony does employ its G-Sensor protection, which disengages the hard drive when the unit is dropped).
The player is comfortable to handle and operate, more so because the A1200 doesn't have extra features such as FM, recording or photo/video support. It is purely a playback device and can handle a variety of formats natively, including MP3, ATRAC3 (plus) and unprotected AAC and WMA files. If you're looking to purchase music, you can do this only by using the relatively unused Connect music store or any MP3 store, such as eMusic. And forget about subscriptions.
While the primary, tactile five-way controller is located slightly lower than we'd like, it's no chore to navigate through menus. The controller, however, is no match for the iPod Click Wheel when browsing through thousands of tracks, despite some fancy shortcuts such as initial-based search (Creative's Zen Vision:M does this much better). Option and Back buttons lie to the right of the controller. A proprietary dock connector is located on the bottom. A somewhat difficult to use volume slider is located on the upper-right spine, while the clear plastic Artist Link button is situated on the opposite side. Sony gets innovative with Artist Link, which finds songs or artists related to the current song.
The all-important Option button pulls up a contextual menu. During playback, for example, hitting it brings up shortcuts to Main Menu, Play Mode, Rating, Sound, Album, Trash Bin and pretty much everything else. You can even access a clock and basic calendar features from here. The main menu, which reminds us of a mobile phone menu, consists of nine icons in a 3-by-3 grid, the centre being Music Library. The other icons represent Play Mode, Initial Search (find artists, album or song by initial), Intelligent Shuffle, Play History, Top 100 songs, Now Playing, Settings and Playlists. We also like the fact that the current song appears on all views, and there are on-the-fly playlists and bookmarking.
Sony attempts to differentiate itself from other brands with features such as Intelligent Shuffle, which gets further broken down into My Favorite Shuffle, Artist Link Shuffle and Time Machine Shuffle (which magically pulls together music from a random year). The idea is that the technology helps pinpoint music out of your immense library on the fly.
While these intelligent features certainly come in handy, they depend on SonicStage software, which has a reputation for being unintuitive and having sluggish transcode and transfer times. In other words, it's no iTunes. Our experience with the latest build (SonicStage CP 4.0) was marginally better with some new features designed for the A1200 -- our transfers of MP3, WMA and AAC files to our A1200 were smooth. Still, SonicStage would not be our first choice for a jukebox. SonicStage CP collects your usage/ratings data, then populates lists such as your top 100 songs or favourite playlists. The Artist Link feature works fairly well and becomes more useful the more songs you have. While we played Boards of Canada, a push of the Artist Link brought up a list of similar ambient electronic songs as well as the artist Orbital. There is no algorithm or wave analysis involved -- the links are based on genre tags.
Performance
While all this 'intelligence' may come off as overkill, the A1200's sound quality rates near the top. The brightness and fullness of the sound (using Grado SRR80) reminds us of the late Sony NW-HD5, which we consider to be one of the all-time best-sounding players. Sound options include six EQ settings, with two custom six-band EQ -- the device also employs Sony's AVLS sound limiter. Battery life is rated for 20 hours when playing back ATRAC files at 48Kbps. Our initial tests of MP3s showed a lower battery life of 14 hours -- still not bad, but far from 20 hours. It's a good thing you can charge the A1200 via USB since the AC adaptor, which uses the same USB cable, is unwieldy.
The A1200 is no doubt a looker, with feminine appeal. But it's also a solid playback device. Outside of the obvious, such as outdoor glare and a scratch-prone screen, the A1200's weakness lies with its dependence on SonicStage software. But if you're a Sony/ATRAC3 fan with a soft spot for pink or purple things and no need for multimedia or FM, this pretty player is for you.
Those looking for more features at the 8GB capacity should check out Creative's older but proven Zen Micro Photo. Also note that sleeker and more feature-filled 8GB flash-based players are just on the horizon.
Edited by James Kim
Additional editing by Kate Macefield
Visit reviews.cnet.co.uk for in-depth reviews of many more products
