Beautiful, sleek design; big, bright display; dual-core CPU; robust software package, including Mac OS X Tiger; illuminated keyboard and scrollable touch pad; DVD burner; built-in Webcam; remote control; can run Windows XP using Apple's free Boot Camp utility
Lacks media card reader and some other ports
With a solid array of components, a terrific set of features and the lightest weight of any laptop its size, Apple's 17-inch MacBook Pro is a power user's dream, but it's not cheap
7.3 Very good
Reviewed by Michelle Thatcher
Following on the heels of the 15.4-inch MacBook Pro and replacing the 17-inch PowerBook G4, the 17-inch MacBook Pro delivers many of the same beloved features as its little sibling, such as a scrolling track pad, the Sudden Motion Sensor and an excellent software package, and adds a huge, bright 17-inch display that's great for graphics work.
Better still, our fully loaded test configuration powered through most of CNET Labs' performance tests, exhibiting only a few of the growing pains encountered by other Intel-based Apple laptops and desktops, such as the iMac Core Duo. Of course, such performance doesn't come cheap -- the 17-inch MacBook Pro's default configuration costs £1,899 (upgrades on our review unit brought the price up further still). But for graphics professionals and other Mac users who have money to spare, the 17-inch MacBook Pro is a dream.
Design
With the MacBook Pro, Apple hasn't radically redesigned the PowerBook form factor, it has just made a few refinements to it. Measuring 391 by 264 by 25mm (WHD), the sleek, aluminium MacBook Pro looks very similar to the 17-inch PowerBook G4 it replaces. At 3.1Kg, the 17-inch MacBook Pro is a fraction lighter than its predecessor and the lightest laptop of its size on the market. With its AC adaptor, which like other Apple laptops connects magnetically to the case, the MacBook Pro weighs 3.6Kg. For the sake of comparison, the Dell Inspiron E1705 weighs 3.7Kg, while the Toshiba Qosmio G35 weighs 4.6Kg.
Features
Underneath the lid, the MacBook Pro extends the tradition of the PowerBook's minimalist design. The MacBook Pro has just a power button, a big keyboard framed by stereo speakers, a very large touch pad with a single mouse button, and a handy built-in iSight camera that sits above the display.
Though the keys are a bit shallow, they're comfortable to type on, and we love the keyboard's backlighting feature, which adjusts to changes in ambient light levels. We don't like that the keyboard is located 137mm back from the laptop's front edge; we wish it were centred to encourage a more ergonomic typing position. The touch pad lets you scroll through long documents, Web pages and spreadsheets by dragging two fingers down or across the pad, a terrific feature that's unique to Apple laptops. Arguably the 17-inch MacBook Pro's most stunning feature is its display -- the large widescreen display features a fine 1,680x1,050 native resolution.
The 17-inch MacBook Pro offers a decent selection of ports and connections, though it comes up a bit short of what you'll find on a similarly sized PC laptop, including the Inspiron E1705. That said, the MacBook Pro features three USB 2.0 ports, FireWire 400 and FireWire 800 ports, an ExpressCard slot and a DVI port (VGA with included adaptor) for connecting to an external monitor. It's also equipped with Bluetooth 2.0+EDR (enhanced data rate), and you can access the Internet via 802.11g Wi-Fi radio and Gigabit Ethernet.
As with the PowerBook, the MacBook Pro features a slot-loading SuperDrive that plays and burns DVDs and CDs. One new extra is the Apple remote that controls the included Front Row multimedia player -- we wish, though, that the MacBook had a storage slot for it. Unlike most PC laptops, the MacBook Pro lacks a built-in media reader for flash memory cards, and there's no S-Video output or built-in modem -- both of which the PowerBook had.
The MacBook Pro ships with Mac OS X Tiger, highlights of which include the incredibly cool Spotlight search utility and the customisable Dashboard, a collection of handy desktop tools. Also included is the robust iLife '06 software suite, Front Row media centre software, and a handful of other applications. In addition, the beta of Boot Camp lets you turn the MacBook into a dual-boot machine that runs full versions of Mac OS X and Windows XP (though you need to purchase a full version of Windows separately).
The 17-inch MacBook Pro comes in one default configuration that costs £1,899. Though there aren't a lot of upgrade options, our review unit included RAM and hard drive enhancements that brought the price up to £2,099. For that much money, you'd expect some pretty high-end specs, and the MacBook delivers -- it has a fast, 2.16GHz Intel Core Duo processor, 2GB of speedy 667MHz DDR2 RAM, an ATI Mobility Radeon X1600 graphics card with 256MB of VRAM, and a blazing 7,200rpm, 100GB hard drive. Still, the MacBook Pro is a bit more expensive than similarly configured Windows laptops.
Performance
CNET Labs compared the 17-inch MacBook Pro to a number of older Apple laptops running the PowerPC processor as well as other Core Duo-based Macs. Unsurprisingly, the MacBook Pro trailed behind a PowerBook G4 when running Sorenson Squeeze, which requires the Rosetta translation program to run on the new chipset. But its ample amount of RAM and quick hard drive helped it power through our Photoshop CS test, in spite of Rosetta. (We expect the MacBook Pro's performance to even out once software publishers release more so-called universal binary apps -- however, we recommend checking if your applications are or will soon be Intel-compatible before buying any new Apple system.)
Of course, on native applications such as iTunes, the 17-inch MacBook Pro saw significant gains over the previous generation of PowerBooks. Probably due to its discrete graphics card, the 17-inch MacBook Pro displayed very respectable Doom 3 frame rates, though its 23.2 frames per second (fps) can't compete with the 56.5fps achieved by the Inspiron E1705 we tested. In our DVD battery-drain test, the MacBook Pro lasted 2 hours, 54 minutes -- quite respectable for a desktop replacement that's not likely to see too much time away from the wall socket.
Apple iBook G4 (1.33GHz, 12-inch)
OS X 10.4.2; PowerPC G4 1.33GHz; 512MB PC2700 333MHz DDR SDRAM; ATI Mobility Radeon 9550 32MB; Fujitsu MHV2040AT 40GB 4,200rpm
Apple MacBook (2GHz Core Duo, 13-inch)
OS 10.4.6; Core Duo 2GHz; 256MB PC5300 666MHz DDR2 SDRAM; Intel GMA950 64MB; Toshiba MK6034GSX 60GB 5,400rpm
Apple MacBook Pro (2.0GHz Core Duo, 15.4-inch)
OS 10.4.6; Core Duo 2GHz; 2GB PC5300 666MHz DDR2 SDRAM; ATI Mobility Radeon x1600 256MB; Toshiba MK1032GSX 100GB 5,400rpm
Apple MacBook Pro (2.16GHz Core Duo, 17-inch)
OS 10.4.6; Core Duo 2.16GHz; 2GB 667MHz DDR2 SDRAM; ATI Mobility Radeon x1600 256MB; Seagate ST910021AS 100GB 7,200rpm
Apple PowerBook G4 (1.5GHz, 12-inch)
OS X 10.4.2; PowerPC G4 1.5GHz; 512MB PC2700 333MHz DDR SDRAM; Nvidia GeForce FX 5200 64MB; Hitachi Travelstar 5K100 80GB 5,400rpm
Edited by Matthew Elliott
Additional editing by Kate Macfield
Visit reviews.cnet.co.uk for in-depth reviews of many more products
