HP Photosmart R927

Print | Close this window

http://reviews.cnet.co.uk/digitalcameras/0,39030233,49267158,00.htm

Reviewed 16 May 2006

Reviewed by Shams Tarek

Most digital cameras come with the assumption that the user has at least some knowledge of photography -- but not HP's Photosmart R927. It might be the 8-megapixel flagship of the company's camera line, but with a menu and help system that's every bit as slick at its sculpted, brushed-aluminium casing, the Photosmart R927 doesn't require you to know anything to get started with this camera. As in the past with some HP cameras, we were less than satisfied with its image quality. Still, very casual photographers are likely to be pleased with the R927, especially if they're just getting into photography, but discerning users will be disappointed with the final output.

As a camera maker, HP is unusual. Even at its most ambitious, the Photosmart line of cameras doesn't try to reach beyond the casual user and amateurs. The Photosmart R927, sporting a big 76mm (3-inch) LCD screen as well as help menus that are more useful than many printed manuals, aids its user to not only understand its operation but to take better pictures, too. Unfortunately, even when you heed the camera's good advice, you'll still contend with its mediocre image quality and its sluggish performance.

Design
With a 3x, f/2.8-to-f/5, 35mm-to-105mm zoom lens (35mm equivalent) and a compact, silver-metal body, the attractive R927 looks like standard fare for today's digital point-and-shoot market. But as much as we like its sleek curves, some of its buttons are awkwardly placed. For example, the flash and macro controls are on top of the camera, making one-handed shooting more difficult.

Its big LCD reveals a unique menu system with plain-language explanations for every setting along with a function that critiques photos you've taken. The Image Advice feature can identify problems with exposure, focus, motion blur and noise due to high ISO or camera temperature. The camera then explains the problem and offers tips on how to improve the image. It also displays tutorials on using its features -- Top Ten Tips that are specific to the camera but also include general photography pointers. Of course, there's also a list of accessories with blurb from the HP marketing department -- "Protect and transport your camera in style with HP's new Signature Collection Cases", one part implores.

Features
Like most digital cameras, the R927 includes a bevy of shooting modes, with in-camera explanations of each. Earning its place at the top of HP's line, this Photosmart includes advanced exposure modes such as aperture priority, shutter priority and full manual.

New to this year's line of Photosmarts is the Design Gallery menu, where you can add borders, rotate, remove red-eye from, or add 'artistic' effects to your images. Each effect is explained in the menu and includes favourites, such as Solarize and Watercolor, as well as some newer twists, such as Slimming. This last option squeezes the middle of the image horizontally, so your subject appears slightly thinner if you centre it in the frame.

Performance
Unfortunately, the HP Photosmart R927 is a sluggish performer under all but optimal conditions. It has an extremely short shutter lag of 0.2 seconds for brightly lit, high-contrast scenes -- that jumps to 1.8 seconds when things aren't so bright. Time from power-on to the first shot was a middling 2.5 seconds, and the camera took 2.8 seconds between shots without flash thereafter. With flash, the shot-to-shot time rose to 3.4 seconds. Also, the burst mode was erratic, capturing anywhere from 1 to 3 images in a burst in our tests at a rate of 2.3fps regardless of image size. The LCD, which initially impressed us with its size, is severely washed out in sunlight. Also, when magnifying images on the LCD, they were noticeably pixelated even when zoomed only slightly, though this probably was not the fault of the LCD.

Image quality
The image quality is not what we'd expect for a camera in its price range. To its credit, the R927 makes excellent exposure decisions, and colours are warm and bright. The lens shows little to no vignetting, but we see severe purple and green fringing around specular highlights as well as high-contrast edges such as white lettering on dark signs or just about anything with the bright sky in the background. Noise levels are not bad. At ISO 100, there is very little noise, aside from some discoloured pixels in darker colours. At ISO 200 and ISO 400, noise is more noticeable but still acceptable, especially for a casual shooter model. We also noticed jaggies in some diagonal lines, while wide-angle shots exhibited significant barrel distortion, in which straight lines near the edges bend outward.

If, for some reason, you're not bothered by the Photosmart R927's image quality or performance issues, its ease of use, its extensive help menus, and its manual exposure controls make it a great camera with which to learn the basics of photography. But if you already know a thing or two and don't need such extensive help functions, you'd probably be better off with a camera with superior image quality, such as Casio's Exilim EX-Z850.

Shooting speed
(Shorter bars indicate better performance)

Typical shot-to-shot time

Time to first shot

Shutter lag (typical)

Sony Cyber Shot DSC-W50

1.5 

1.6 

0.3 

HP Photosmart R927

2.8 

2.5 

0.3 

Canon PowerShot SD630

1.9 

1.4 

0.5 

Casio Exilim EX-Z850

2.7 

2.1 

0.5 

Canon PowerShot A620

1.8 

1.9 

0.7 

Note: Seconds

Typical continuous-shooting speed
(Longer bars indicate better performance)

HP Photosmart R927

2.3 

Sony Cyber Shot DSC-W50

2.1 

Canon PowerShot SD630

2.1 

Canon PowerShot A620

1.7 

Casio Exilim EX-Z850

1 

Note: Frames per second

Edited by Philip Ryan
Additional editing by Kate Macefield