Philips GoGear HDD6320 Jukebox (30GB)

Print | Close this window

http://reviews.cnet.co.uk/digitalmusic/0,39029995,39195043,00.htm

Reviewed 12 January 2006

Reviewed by Troy Dreier

Music lovers who want the iPod's style but would rather stick to something compatible with Windows Media Player and Windows Media DRM 10 should give some consideration to Philips' GoGear HDD6320 Jukebox, a sexy black portable that offers 30GB of storage, photo viewing on a bright, clear screen and even a few tricks that the iPod hasn't learned. We found the player for around £195 online, which compares favourably with £219 for the current 30GB iPod.

While the snazzy touch-sensitive interface isn't for everybody, this Windows Media DRM 10-compatible player is a nice step forward for Philips MP3 players, which have suffered from performance issues in the past. Although we have heard some reports of the HDD6320 suffering from processor slowness -- including one from a CNET employee who has used the device -- we didn't experience any major problems ourselves during testing.

Design
The Philips GoGear HDD6320 Jukebox resembles the new black iPod, although at 64 by 104 by 17mm, it's noticeably thicker (the 30GB iPod is 10mm thick and 136g), and it weighs more at 150g. But its elegant design does have a similar sleekness and gor-blimey factor, something we can't say about most WMA-compatible players. The player's smooth black face doesn't show any controls or buttons at first. When you power it up, backlit blue buttons appear to show you your touch-sensitive input options. You'll get only the buttons that work with the menu you're on -- so if you've scrolled all the way to the right, you won't get the Move Forward button, for example -- which is a clever design and is reminiscent of the iRiver U10 and the Olympus M:robe series. It has three Playback buttons on the top, Forward and Back buttons on the sides, a scroll bar in the middle and the Menu button on the lower left.

The HDD6320's design has drawbacks, though. The controls are so spread out -- besides the already mentioned buttons, there are dedicated volume buttons on the right side, as well as a power and a hold slider button on the left -- that it's hard to operate the player with one hand, as you can do with an iPod. The buttons on the face are touch-sensitive but don't have any mechanical parts, so there's no tactile response when you press them. That makes them too easy to click by mistake -- or not to click when you think you're tapping them. Plus, the glossy front is a magnet for skin oil and fingerprints, and it starts to look messy after only a little use.

The HDD6320 has a bright 51mm (2-inch) TFT screen capable of 65k colours and eight lines of text. It's not as big as the video-capable iPod's 64mm screen, but it still does a good job of showing off album art, photos, and even slide shows with music and transitions. It can't store and play video, though, like the new iPod or Cowon's iAudio X5.

The HDD6320's 51mm screen is bright and colourful

The HDD6320 comes with a pair of black headphones that have a rubbery coating, making them tangle-prone and quick to catch on jacket zips. They sounded great in our testing, producing an even, rich tone with enough bass, although they leak sound so that music at higher volumes can easily be heard by others.

The package also comes with a cloth slipcase, though you can't control the player while it's in the case, so you'll constantly be removing it. When you're ready to expand, Philips has a small line of compatible accessories, including a carrying case with a carabiner clip, a docking cradle for connecting to your stereo or TV, and a camera cable for loading photos from your camera without a PC.

Features
The Philips GoGear HDD6320 Jukebox features a simple side-scrolling interface, with all the different areas arranged on the right side of the main screen: Music, Pictures, Recordings, Settings and Now Playing. Clicking the Menu button on any screen brings up contextual commands, such as assigning presets in the radio section. We're happy to see a voice recorder, since Apple's iPod doesn't have one. Unfortunately, you won't be able to record line-in sources unless you have the optional dock. When playing music, you can select from ten preset equaliser settings, manually adjust the five-band equaliser, and turn on the SRS Wow bass enhancer. The player can handle MP3, protected WMA and WAV tracks, but will connect only with Windows XP PCs.

Photo integration is done well, with useful slide-show options and simultaneous viewing and listening. When you're viewing photos with music playing, you can control the music tracks with the top row of controls while using the scroll bar to look through photos so that you can move between tracks without leaving the photo section -- you can't do that with the iPod. Also, the HDD6320 can act as a USB host, so you can transfer photos over from a digital camera.

Loading the HDD6320 is simple, as it works seamlessly with Windows Media Player. The package includes an installation disc, but luckily there's no proprietary software to complicate things. You can load your own ripped songs with the included USB 2.0 cord or buy them from an online music service. The player supports WMP DRM 10 (sometimes known as Janus), so it works with subscription plans. We tested it with Napster 3.5 subscription content, and it loaded exactly as it should have.

Performance
The Philips GoGear HDD6320 Jukebox's sound quality is nice and bright, even with the bundled headphones. Crisp highs and a presence of bass that the iPod can't quite match were the norm for all types of music. In the past, Philips's hard drive-based MP3 players have had some processor-performance issues, such as system crashes and slow navigation between files and/or menus. The HDD6320 is a vast improvement, though some users have reported similar bugginess and overall slow performance, especially when playing back long playlists and, in some instances, subscription files. Since we didn't experience any noticeable problems ourselves, all we can assume is that there might be some bad apples in the bunch.

In our testing, we were able to load songs at an average rate of 4.9MB per second over USB 2.0, which is on a par with what we've seen from other players. The HDD6320 is rated for 15 to 17 hours of battery life; different product literature has different numbers. We measured 15.6 hours in a battery-drain test with the equaliser off, while we measured 17.5 hours in casual testing. Either battery time is good, but not exceptional. Charging the battery takes 4 hours, although you can do a 70 per cent fast charge in 1 hour. Sadly, the battery isn't user-replaceable.

Edited by James Kim
Additional editing by Nick Hide