Apple Mac Mini (1.25GHz)

Print | Close this window

http://reviews.cnet.co.uk/desktops/0,39029981,39188861,00.htm

Reviewed 2 February 2005

Reviewed by Troy Dreier

Apple has tried everything to get Windows users to switch to the Mac. First, it created a revolutionary operating system, Mac OS X, then it launched the 'Switch' ad campaign, with former Windows users frankly explaining why they like Macs better. When these efforts didn't produce the intended results, Apple employed a more straightforward strategy: make Macs cheaper.

With the Mac Mini, Apple has finally conceded the possibility that most people shopping for a desktop choose price above all else and don't want to throw away their expensive monitors to move to the Mac platform. Now, at £339 (as of May 2005), the standalone Mini (and it really stands alone, without a keyboard, a mouse, speakers or a monitor) offers would-be Apple converts a more affordable and flexible, but still stylish, entry-level Mac.

Its performance limitations make it glacially slow at processor-intensive tasks, so power users should look elsewhere; but for everyday home computing, it's a great buy. Even with a few recommended upgrades, the Mac Mini still costs less than £550, an enticing price point for investigating the Mac platform and the included software, such as the bundled iLife '05 suite.

Design
Apple has become synonymous with sleek, minimalist design and the Mac Mini certainly embodies this ethos. A low, square box with rounded corners, the Mini is made of white plastic and anodised aluminium, and it measures 165 by 51 by 165mm and weighs 1.3kg. Smaller than any Shuttle system we've seen (and Shuttle pioneered the small form-factor PC), the Mini looks great in any environment, equally at home on a desk or in the lounge. And when in use, the Mini is marvellously quiet, with its cooling fan producing less than a whisper.

Minimal Mini: setting up the Mac Mini is easy -- just plug in the power cord and find yourself a monitor, a keyboard, and a mouse

True to Apple's styling, the top of the Mac Mini displays the simple Apple logo, and on the front there's only a slot-loading CD/DVD drive and a small white power light. In order to maintain the Mini's elegance, Apple has put even commonly used items, including the power button and the audio jack, on the rear. You may tire of feeling around the back to turn it on or sync your iPod, but the Mini's small dimensions mean it will likely be sitting on top of your desk rather than under it, making its back-panel ports more convenient than they would be on a tower design.

Also on the back of the Mac Mini, you'll find two USB 2.0 ports, one FireWire 400 port, a 10/100BaseT Ethernet port, a modem port (for the included 56Kbps V.92 modem) and a DVI video-out port. We were happy to see the Mini ships with a DVI-to-VGA video adapter so that users can connect both digital and analogue monitors. We were less than happy to find only a pair of USB ports: unless your monitor or keyboard provides such ports, you'll need to get a USB hub. It's far from a big-ticket item, but it will somewhat diminish the Mini's small footprint and clean design.

We would like more than two USB ports, but we were happy to see a FireWire port and a DVI connection for monitors

The Mini's case isn't sealed, but opening it is a challenge and not for the nontechnical (it involves some elbow grease and confidence with a putty knife). If you want Bluetooth, Wi-Fi or extra RAM, we recommend ordering them as custom options when you buy the Mini or taking it to a local Apple repair shop. Adding an AirPort Extreme card is especially challenging, since besides installing the card, you'll also need to add an internal antenna. If you plan to shuttle the Mini from room to room, as Apple suggests, you'll want to tack on the wireless upgrade before you buy.

Features
We tested the basic £339 Mac Mini, which gives you a 1.25GHz G4 processor, 256MB RAM, a 40GB hard drive and a combo drive (CD-RW/DVD-ROM). Apple also sells a £399 Mini that has a faster 1.4GHz G4 processor and a larger 80GB hard drive.

The Mini comes hobbled with only 256MB of RAM, which makes it a poor performer (see 'Performance') for any processor-intensive applications, including editing video or high-resolution photos and playing 3D games. Memory has long been a shortcoming in Macs, including both the iMac G5 and even a couple of Power Mac G5 configurations, which also ship as standard with 256MB of memory. (In fairness to the G5 machines, they do use faster 400MHz memory, but 256MB is still not enough.)

If Apple wants its computers to be seen as cutting-edge media machines, it should make 512MB RAM the standard and ship high-end machines with a full gigabyte. We'd recommend that anyone eyeing the Mini spend £30 to double the memory to 512MB. And if you plan to make use of iMovie and iDVD, you'll want to upgrade the combo drive to Apple's DVD-burning SuperDrive. That upgrade was more costly than we expected at £70.

The £339 Mac Mini is certainly easy on the eyes, but we'd make four upgrades that would raise the price by £200 before we brought one home

Performance
In our real-world testing, the Mini's limited RAM meant it performed complex tasks much more slowly than a Power Mac G5 would, but the difference was usually in seconds, not minutes. Working with clips in iMovie was noticeably slower, but never so slow that we needed to make a cup of tea while the machine caught up. Transferring an iMovie file to iDVD, however, gave us more than enough time to fetch a cuppa. The Mini also choked on GarageBand songs with several instrumental tracks, occasionally pausing for a split second in the middle of a song during playback.

In addition to the memory, the slow-spinning hard drive contributes to the Mac Mini's performance limitations. In order to pack it into such a small case, Apple uses a notebook hard drive. Whereas the iMac G5 uses a 99mm (3.5-inch), 7200rpm drive, inside the Mini spins a 71mm (2.5-inch), 4200rpm drive. Expansion, or lack thereof, is also another obvious drawback to the Mini; there are no free PCI slots and opening the case is difficult.

One way Apple has kept the Mini's price down is by not including a monitor, a keyboard, or a mouse. If you're switching from a Windows computer, that won't be a problem, because Macs can use nearly any peripherals that Windows PCs can use -- as long as your keyboard and mouse are USB and not PS/2. If you're a new user, however, you'll need to tack on the extra expense (Apple offers a wireless keyboard and mouse kit for £70).

We recommend a Logitech or Microsoft mouse and keyboard (Apple's one-button mouse and rinky-dink plastic keyboard are so poor that it's probably a plus that the Mini doesn't come with them). You can also configure the Mini with wireless capability: Bluetooth for wireless keyboard and mouse -- saving valuable USB ports in the process -- and 802.11g for wireless networking. Apple offers both for a reasonable £70.

The £339 price pulled us in, but when we were done with customising the Mac Mini the way we'd want it, the price rose to £539 with four upgrades: doubling the memory (£30) and the hard drive (£30), upgrading to the SuperDrive (£70), and adding wireless Bluetooth and the AirPort Extreme card (£70). While other budget PCs beat the Mac Mini on hardware, the Mini has the edge -- in addition to its small footprint and quiet operation -- with its software bundle.

The Mini comes with the recently released iLife '05 suite, which includes iMovie HD, iTunes 4.7, iDVD 5.0, iPhoto 5.0, and GarageBand 2.0. You also get AppleWorks (oddly, the Mini doesn't come with iWork, Apple's new office suite) and a few kid-friendly games. The abundant software bundle greatly adds to the Mini's overall value.

Application performance
Using an older, slower G4 processor, the Mac Mini couldn't keep pace with its G5 family members on our Photoshop benchmark. Also hurting its performance was its piddling allotment of memory: the Mac Mini ships with 256MB of RAM, while the iMac G5 and the Power Mac G5 models we tested had 512MB and 4GB respectively. The Mac Mini took 23 minutes, 1 second to complete our test of applying a variety of techniques to 15 images. The iMac G5 completed the same test in 8 minutes, 31 seconds, and the Power Mac breezed though the test in 3 minutes, 13 seconds -- more than seven times faster than the Mac Mini.

But that's to be expected; the Power Mac G5, for one, has two processors to the Mini's one -- each of which is clocked twice as fast -- and it has eight times the memory. For lengthy photo-editing sessions, you may grow frustrated with the Mini's modest specs. If your photo editing rarely goes beyond reducing red-eye, then the Mini can save you a bundle and still suit your needs. We do recommend, however, spending the additional £30 to upgrade the Mini's memory to 512MB.

The Mac Mini had a better showing on our iTunes test, taking just over 45 seconds to convert a 10 minute song (in AIFF) to MP3. It still trailed the iMac G5 and the Power Mac G5, but not by nearly as large a margin as our Photoshop test. And the Mini narrowly outpaced the similarly equipped eMac, which we attribute to the optimisations Apple has made to Mac OS X between versions X 10.3.3 and 10.3.7. Editor's note: since this review was written, Apple has started equipping the Mac Mini with Mac OS X 10.4, better known as Tiger.

Photoshop CS
(Shorter bars indicate better performance)

(Time in minutes)

Power Mac G5 dual 2.5GHz (4,096MB DDR SDRAM 400MHz)

3.22

Apple iMac G5 (1.8GHz PowerPC G5, 512MB DDR SDRAM 400MHz)

8.52

Apple Mac Mini (1.25GHz PowerPC G4, 256MB DDR SDRAM 333MHz)

23.02

We use Adobe Photoshop to evaluate a system's performance as an integrated whole -- the CPU, the memory, the hard disk and the graphics card. We run an automated suite of operations that simultaneously stresses a variety of the machine's subsystems and simulates a real-world Web-production work flow. The suite includes launching the application; converting between colour spaces and bit depths; applying a variety of filters; working with layers, selection areas and alpha channels; and resizing and compressing images. We time how long it takes to run the suite on 15 files that range from 1.8MB to 49.2MB and in 8- and 16-bit colour.

iTunes
(Shorter bars indicate better performance)

(Time in seconds)

Power Mac G5 dual 2.5GHz (4,096MB DDR SDRAM 400MHz)

17.9

Apple iMac G5 (1.8GHz PowerPC G5, 512MB DDR SDRAM 400MHz)

37.3

Apple Mac Mini (1.25GHz PowerPC G4, 256MB DDR SDRAM 333MHz)

45.2

Apple eMac (1.25GHz PowerPC G4, 256MB DDR SDRAM, 333MHz)

46.5

We use Apple iTunes as another indicator of a system's performance. In this test, we time how long it takes to convert a 107MB AIFF audio file to MP3.

Graphics and gaming performance
The Mac Mini produced a playable frame rate on our Quake III benchmark at just over 60fps, but before you get too excited, we should note that Quake III is an older game, and the test was run at a fairly low resolution of 1024x768. The Mini's 32MB ATI Radeon 9200 is a step up from an integrated graphics solution that borrows resources from main system memory, but it's still not a card you'd find in a high-end gaming system. Today's games, though not generally available for Macs, will prove too taxing for the Mini. Then again, any gamer shopping for a £339 computer couldn't expect to run the latest software. The Mini can handle running the apps found in iLife '05 -- for manipulating photos, music and movies -- which should keep most prospective Mini owners pleased and productive.

Quake III
(Longer bars indicate better performance)

(Frames per second)

Power Mac G5 dual 2.5GHz (ATI Radeon 9800)

319.1

Apple iMac G5 (Nvidia GeForce FX 5200)

72.2

Apple eMac G4 1.25GHz (ATI Radeon 9200)

68.8

Apple Mac Mini (ATI Radeon 9200)

60.7

To measure 3D gaming performance, we use Quake III Arena for OS X. Although Quake III is an older game, it is still widely used as an industry-standard tool.

System configurations:

Apple eMac
Mac OS X 10.3.3; 1.25GHz PowerPC G4; 256MB DDR SDRAM 333MHz; 32MB ATI Radeon 9200; 80GB 7,200rpm Ultra ATA/100

Apple iMac G5
Mac OS X 10.3.5; 1.8GHz PowerPC G5; 512MB DDR SDRAM 400MHz; 64MB Nvidia GeForce FX 5200; 80GB 7,200rpm Serial ATA

Apple Mac Mini
Mac OS X 10.3.7; 1.25GHz PowerPC G4; 256MB DDR SDRAM 333MHz; 32MB ATI Radeon 9200; 40GB 4,200rpm Ultra ATA/100

Apple Power Mac G5 dual 2.5GHz
Mac OS X 10.3.5; Dual 2.5GHz PowerPC G5; 4,096MB DDR SDRAM 400MHz; 256MB ATI Radeon 9800; 160GB 7,200rpm Serial ATA

Edited by Matthew Elliot
Additional editing by Nick Hide